2013 Indians 1st round pick: CF Clint Frazier
With their 1st round pick in the 2013 Draft the Cleveland Indians have selected center fielder Clint Frazier out of Loganville High School (GA).
Born: 09/06/1994 - Height: 5’11” - Weight: 185 - Bats: Right - Throws: Right
Baseball America: 4th
Jonathan Mayo: 4th
Keith Law: 7th
Perfect Game: 4th
John Sickels: 2nd (for hitters)
Tony’s quick take: The draft went as expected as Appel, Gray, Bryant and Stewart all went off the board before the Indians pick, and the Indians followed up with the player we at the IBI predicted all day long. Frazier is a premium bat with amazing bat speed and showed off some big time power in private workouts for the Indians and other clubs. Even though he is only a high school player, his future potential is that of a franchise player because of his incredible makeup and good skills all across the board. His all-out playstyle should be familiar to Indians fans as it is a lot like Grady Sizemore. He is only average sized, but because of some very good strength in his arms, hard and wrists he really showcases some raw power. He has an aggressive approach so may be prone to high strikeout totals, do discipline could be an ongoing issue for him. He is raw in center field but athletic and has above average arm strength, but the Indians believe he can play there. There were other good talents available when they picked, and time may prove that others were better, but this was the right pick to make at the time of the draft because of his impact potential.
Jeff Ellis: I have been saying for a while that the national media is off on the Indians. They might have been extremely conservative in the past but times have changed. Frazier fits everything the Indians have looked for over the past four years. He plays up the middle, though he supposedly will move to left field. He is a very good athlete, great speed, arm, and strength. He also has the grit and fire this team loves. Frazier doesn't take a minute off. He is a gym rat, who will out work you. He loves the game, and it's an obsession, maybe even an addiction to him. He has the best bat speed I have ever seen. He just turns around so quick on a ball. He was fourth on my board, and I had him mocked to the Indians. I think he is a future All Star. This is exactly the player I wanted them to get here and can't wait to see him play later this summer. I am curious about him being listed as a third baseman, as he could do it. He has a better chance there than in center and much more valuable than he would be in left field. For the past month my comp for Frazier has been David Wright. Maybe the Indians really agree with me. End of the day they got a guy who was a near consensus number four player in this draft at the fifth pick, that is a good day.
Andrew Zajac: I love the Frazier selection. For years, the Indians were known as taking "safe" college players and in recent years, they've reversed that trend. This pick had to be between Colin Moran, Braden Shipley, and Clint Frazier. Easily, Clint Frazier was the right pick for the Tribe.
Frazier is considered a center fielder, but in my opinion, projects more as a corner outfielder, maybe right field. He has some of the quickest bat speed seen in a prospect in a long time. He plays with a ton of energy and gives 110 percent effort every time out. Frazier also has some great raw power. In a private workout, he hit 16 home runs on 24 swings. He's average to slightly above average on the bases and also has a strong arm in the outfield which could be considered as a plus tool. The biggest concern with Frazier is his physical projection. Most say that he won't add much power or strength as he adds muscle to his frame, so what you see is what you get out of Frazier. In general, he's unlikely to get much bigger than he currently is.
Frazier has the potential to be a star in this league. Peter Gammons stated that he has a "franchise personality." He won't move very fast through the system, but will quickly become one of the best prospects in the Indians farm system. Indians' fans should be very pleased with this selection.
The Cleveland Indians today announced the selection of OF CLINT FRAZIER with the 5th overall selection in the first round of the 2013 First-Year Player Draft.
Frazier, 18, recently graduated from Loganville High School in Loganville, Georgia, where he batted .485 in his senior campaign (47-for-97) with 17 homers, 45 RBI, 56 runs scored, a .561 on-base pct and a 1.134 slugging pct in 32 games. Following the season, the 5’11” right-handed hitter was named the Gatorade National Baseball Player of the Year.
As a junior at Loganville in 2012, he hit .424 with 24 home runs, earning 2012 All-American honors from Aflac and Under Armour while leading the Loganville Red Devils to the AAAA Georgia state championship. In all, Clint hit a school record 63 home runs throughout his prep career. He has a verbal commit to attend the University of Georgia and is the first overall high school position player selected in the 2013 draft. He is attending the draft at the MLB Network Studios.
Follow Tony and the Indians Baseball Insider on Twitter @TonyIBI. Also, his new book the 2013 Cleveland Indians Baseball Insider which profiles the Indians' Top 100 Prospects and more is available for sale.
The comparisons to Mantle though...c'mon...really?? I never saw Mantle play but my grandfather did and said he was the fastest guy he ever saw from home to first. I don't think Frazier has his speed.
There actually is grey area though. He's deserved of the #5 slot for the Indians, and his upside is unquestioned...but it's okay to look at the kid's size and think, "not prototypical." It's also okay to look at his bat speed and think, "Yeah, that's freakish."
You know...it's actually possible to have good points on both sides...
Now it's his turn to prove that all the intangibles equal a #1 pick...size be damned...
This is what seperates baseball from the other sports.
He wasn't his "advisor" at least.
Now...I concur with you about size not being an issue with a kid with Frazier's upside for many reasons...but it can't be excluded...
and I don't read Baseball America...whenever I can help it. I never look at it prior to drafts, and rarely worry about size until I actually see them play with my own eyes. You generally see these kids at their best in the vids, but the key--to me--is always what they do when they aren't hitting or making great plays.
I'm frustrated by a lot of talk about players that have only seen them by second and third hand sources. It's tough in baseball, because of the nature of it...so you do what you can...
I love the draft, and I'll be taking part in the coverage tonight here at IBI...but I always take the talk about players with a grain of salt...let them make their picks...
then let me take a look at them.
Hopefully, the draftniks for the Indians have ACTUALLY WATCHED THEM PLAY...lol...which over the years...I wonder about...
Willie Mays 5'-10- 170
Eric Davis weighed 165 pounds and hit 282 career homers. I could go on and on. Fraziers size is no concern whatsoever. Stop reading baseball America scouting reports.
Of course, had Appel signed with Boras officially prior to last years draft, there would have been less concern, but it's a common strategy use by many players to hold leverage over teams.
"The Power zone" is what George Foreman called it.
He has Mickey Mantle-like strength and bat speed.
However, that build will cause two problems down the road.
1. Throwing will become increasingly difficult.
Left field is the right position for him rather than letting him become injured like Travis Hafner was.
2. Getting his bat through his swing without hitting his chest may become difficult forcing him to step in the bucket or swing like Pete Rose, Grady Sizemore, Hafner, etc., standing in the bucket then stepping towards the plate.
Great choice, all-in-all for Cleveland.
I think he's the best pick of the Grant era......I am a big Lindor fan and think his game will be great but I think Frazier will be the face of the franchise starting around '17.....maybe the best position player pick since Manny.
I suspect we revert to the standard pattern of torching the next two or three picks on pitchers who will flame out before they get to AA ball.