2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
criznit2009 wrote:Anyone else starting to think that Head needs to given a shot this year? Starting to think he might be a better gamble then Huffman - if he keeps this up till mid-June he has to get a shot right? Other than his K's he is putting up some tasty numbers. Would Head have any trade value besides cash - time to do some clearing out in Columbus it just is too crowded and guys who are all ML options.
Thing that hurts Head is age and the fact that he only has 3 walks on the year. Guy is killing the ball but Tribe likes guys that can take a walk. Don't get me wrong, he's a guy I'd love to see get a shot. Hitting .379 against both righties and lefties (though his OBP is actually only .367 against lefties). Leads the IL in batting average and 4th in OPS...
As far as value...other than a throw in for a multiplayer deal, cash is really the best you could hope for.
- Hermie13
- MLB All Star
- Posts: 6468
- Joined: Wed Oct 22, 2008 11:34 am
- Location: Cleveland, OH
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
Mlbtraderumors is reporting Bubba Bell was traded to the Mets for cash.
- homerawayfromhome
- Double-A Hot Shot
- Posts: 1794
- Joined: Sun Aug 15, 2010 9:17 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
homerawayfromhome wrote:Mlbtraderumors is reporting Bubba Bell was traded to the Mets for cash.
Seemed like a pretty pointless signing at the time just extra depth... I wonder if we made anything on the deal. would be funny to find out me made $ 13.72 or something like that.
- criznit2009
- Double-A Hot Shot
- Posts: 1133
- Joined: Tue May 12, 2009 9:27 pm
- Location: Portland, OR
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
Hermie13 wrote:criznit2009 wrote:Anyone else starting to think that Head needs to given a shot this year? Starting to think he might be a better gamble then Huffman - if he keeps this up till mid-June he has to get a shot right? Other than his K's he is putting up some tasty numbers. Would Head have any trade value besides cash - time to do some clearing out in Columbus it just is too crowded and guys who are all ML options.
Thing that hurts Head is age and the fact that he only has 3 walks on the year. Guy is killing the ball but Tribe likes guys that can take a walk. Don't get me wrong, he's a guy I'd love to see get a shot. Hitting .379 against both righties and lefties (though his OBP is actually only .367 against lefties). Leads the IL in batting average and 4th in OPS...
As far as value...other than a throw in for a multiplayer deal, cash is really the best you could hope for.
Problem for Head is he is just not viewed as much of a prospect. He is hitting the crap out of the ball right now, but the general feeling is he will struggle big time at the next level because of his inability as Herm said to take a walk, work counts, etc. He has lots of holes in his swing and can be pitched to.
That all said, he is certainly playing himself into consideration for a minor league deal with another team after this season as I believe off the top of my head he is a MLFA. May get a shot elsewhere as a bit player.
-

TonyIBI - MLB Rookie
- Posts: 5047
- Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2008 11:03 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
TonyIPI wrote:That all said, he is certainly playing himself into consideration for a minor league deal with another team after this season as I believe off the top of my head he is a MLFA. May get a shot elsewhere as a bit player.
I thought he was a MLFA this last year, so I'm pretty sure he's going to be one this year.
-

Edible14 - Single-A Phenom
- Posts: 903
- Joined: Sun Apr 04, 2010 11:49 am
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
Here's an interesting prospect to watch for
German SS 17 year old Cavan Cohones verballed to Ohio St batted. 446 last year over seas and had a. 925 fielding percentage. In a 40 yard dash he ran a 4.33 and hit 95 on the radar gun with his throwing shoulder having an injury, most say he never steps foot at Ohio St. The Yankees, Twins and Seattle are very interested. He ran a 60 in 6.40 (Kevin Washington ran a 6.3) he is 6'1 175 from a camp in Cleveland. He also had 27 Stolen bases, he has relatives in Youngstown, Ohio and is from SD, California. He was 1st team all europe, he also had 19 HR. He is pretty much the european bryce harper
German SS 17 year old Cavan Cohones verballed to Ohio St batted. 446 last year over seas and had a. 925 fielding percentage. In a 40 yard dash he ran a 4.33 and hit 95 on the radar gun with his throwing shoulder having an injury, most say he never steps foot at Ohio St. The Yankees, Twins and Seattle are very interested. He ran a 60 in 6.40 (Kevin Washington ran a 6.3) he is 6'1 175 from a camp in Cleveland. He also had 27 Stolen bases, he has relatives in Youngstown, Ohio and is from SD, California. He was 1st team all europe, he also had 19 HR. He is pretty much the european bryce harper
- ClevBuck
- Draft Prospect
- Posts: 103
- Joined: Sat Apr 09, 2011 9:42 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
That was ment for 2011 draft thread
- ClevBuck
- Draft Prospect
- Posts: 103
- Joined: Sat Apr 09, 2011 9:42 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
TonyIPI wrote:Hermie13 wrote:criznit2009 wrote:Anyone else starting to think that Head needs to given a shot this year? Starting to think he might be a better gamble then Huffman - if he keeps this up till mid-June he has to get a shot right? Other than his K's he is putting up some tasty numbers. Would Head have any trade value besides cash - time to do some clearing out in Columbus it just is too crowded and guys who are all ML options.
Thing that hurts Head is age and the fact that he only has 3 walks on the year. Guy is killing the ball but Tribe likes guys that can take a walk. Don't get me wrong, he's a guy I'd love to see get a shot. Hitting .379 against both righties and lefties (though his OBP is actually only .367 against lefties). Leads the IL in batting average and 4th in OPS...
As far as value...other than a throw in for a multiplayer deal, cash is really the best you could hope for.
Problem for Head is he is just not viewed as much of a prospect. He is hitting the crap out of the ball right now, but the general feeling is he will struggle big time at the next level because of his inability as Herm said to take a walk, work counts, etc. He has lots of holes in his swing and can be pitched to.
That all said, he is certainly playing himself into consideration for a minor league deal with another team after this season as I believe off the top of my head he is a MLFA. May get a shot elsewhere as a bit player.
Agree with everything here. He's a guy that will be in the MLs eventually....maybe just in a Jonathan Van Every role, but like you said some team out there could use him (NL team?) as a bit player.
Starting to think we should just let Kearns go and give Head a 2 week trial. Worst case he does suck...but then you just DFA him too. Not a guy you really should care if he is claimed (can't see him being claimed anyways). Can't really be much worse than Kearns IMO....
- Hermie13
- MLB All Star
- Posts: 6468
- Joined: Wed Oct 22, 2008 11:34 am
- Location: Cleveland, OH
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
Hermie13 wrote:Starting to think we should just let Kearns go and give Head a 2 week trial. Worst case he does suck...but then you just DFA him too. Not a guy you really should care if he is claimed (can't see him being claimed anyways). Can't really be much worse than Kearns IMO....
Can't believe I am defending Kearns....but while Head may be no worse or could be better offensively than Kearns.....Kearns is 2-3 times the defender that Head is. It's another reason Head hasn't ever been given much of a chance....sure he plays everywhere, just not that great at any one position.
-

TonyIBI - MLB Rookie
- Posts: 5047
- Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2008 11:03 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
TonyIPI wrote:Hermie13 wrote:Starting to think we should just let Kearns go and give Head a 2 week trial. Worst case he does suck...but then you just DFA him too. Not a guy you really should care if he is claimed (can't see him being claimed anyways). Can't really be much worse than Kearns IMO....
Can't believe I am defending Kearns....but while Head may be no worse or could be better offensively than Kearns.....Kearns is 2-3 times the defender that Head is. It's another reason Head hasn't ever been given much of a chance....sure he plays everywhere, just not that great at any one position.
Please don't defend Kearns...Head isn't an option really and compared to Kearns....UGGGH... Kearns wins. Head is strictly a bat, his D is a liabilty for the ML club and would have to be a bench only kinda option. Getting to the point where we have to bring up Phelps, it would be an excellent addition He could start 3-5 games a week if he can hold down 3rd base well enough. Infield was already crowded and then Jrod came back and now Goedert is back. If Head is still steam rolling in mid June, then who knows could help the team or maybe get some cash for the big one.
- criznit2009
- Double-A Hot Shot
- Posts: 1133
- Joined: Tue May 12, 2009 9:27 pm
- Location: Portland, OR
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
criznit2009 wrote:TonyIPI wrote:Hermie13 wrote:Starting to think we should just let Kearns go and give Head a 2 week trial. Worst case he does suck...but then you just DFA him too. Not a guy you really should care if he is claimed (can't see him being claimed anyways). Can't really be much worse than Kearns IMO....
Can't believe I am defending Kearns....but while Head may be no worse or could be better offensively than Kearns.....Kearns is 2-3 times the defender that Head is. It's another reason Head hasn't ever been given much of a chance....sure he plays everywhere, just not that great at any one position.
Please don't defend Kearns...Head isn't an option really and compared to Kearns....UGGGH... Kearns wins. Head is strictly a bat, his D is a liabilty for the ML club and would have to be a bench only kinda option. Getting to the point where we have to bring up Phelps, it would be an excellent addition He could start 3-5 games a week if he can hold down 3rd base well enough. Infield was already crowded and then Jrod came back and now Goedert is back. If Head is still steam rolling in mid June, then who knows could help the team or maybe get some cash for the big one.
Since they made the move with goedert, I have wondered if the Indians did it with the idea he could be the Rh option off the bench at 1b, LF and Dh if he hits well and defends adequately. Just a thought.
- indianinkslinger
- Triple-A Stud
- Posts: 2493
- Joined: Fri Sep 19, 2008 12:11 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
TonyIPI wrote:Hermie13 wrote:Starting to think we should just let Kearns go and give Head a 2 week trial. Worst case he does suck...but then you just DFA him too. Not a guy you really should care if he is claimed (can't see him being claimed anyways). Can't really be much worse than Kearns IMO....
Can't believe I am defending Kearns....but while Head may be no worse or could be better offensively than Kearns.....Kearns is 2-3 times the defender that Head is. It's another reason Head hasn't ever been given much of a chance....sure he plays everywhere, just not that great at any one position.
Well with Grady hurting it makes sense but when he's healthy, you dont' need a defensive whiz that can play LF. Especially since Duncan hasn't been as bad as he was in the past (actually has looked respectable in LF this year).
- Hermie13
- MLB All Star
- Posts: 6468
- Joined: Wed Oct 22, 2008 11:34 am
- Location: Cleveland, OH
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
Buck recalled to Indians (Sizemore on DL)
I panicked for a moment when the Indy Indians broadcast had the Lonnie Chisenhall graphic up when Chase D'arnaud was batting. I thought "What! We traded Chiz to the Pirates! For what!"
Blue caps again. I'm beginning to think the gray/blue ones aren't even in their lockers.
I panicked for a moment when the Indy Indians broadcast had the Lonnie Chisenhall graphic up when Chase D'arnaud was batting. I thought "What! We traded Chiz to the Pirates! For what!"
Blue caps again. I'm beginning to think the gray/blue ones aren't even in their lockers.
- Upper Box Woodchuck
- Single-A Phenom
- Posts: 786
- Joined: Tue Mar 24, 2009 2:47 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
criznit2009 wrote:homerawayfromhome wrote:Mlbtraderumors is reporting Bubba Bell was traded to the Mets for cash.
Seemed like a pretty pointless signing at the time just extra depth... I wonder if we made anything on the deal. would be funny to find out me made $ 13.72 or something like that.
Casino vouchers for the Clippers coaching staff when they visit the Bisons.

- Upper Box Woodchuck
- Single-A Phenom
- Posts: 786
- Joined: Tue Mar 24, 2009 2:47 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
Upper Box Woodchuck wrote:Buck recalled to Indians (Sizemore on DL).
Eligible to come off May 26th...but man, seemed like Acta was pretty optimistic with him as recent as yesterday.
- Hermie13
- MLB All Star
- Posts: 6468
- Joined: Wed Oct 22, 2008 11:34 am
- Location: Cleveland, OH
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
On the bright side, so far a solid outing from Kluber. 6 innings and only 2 runs on 4 hits. Worked out of a jam there in the 6th with a run in and runner on third with 1 out. Got out of it though preserving the 3-2 lead.
- Hermie13
- MLB All Star
- Posts: 6468
- Joined: Wed Oct 22, 2008 11:34 am
- Location: Cleveland, OH
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
Kipnis trying to give the Indians a reason to call him up leads off with a HR. Phelps up next...HR. Good stuff
- Lloyd Christmas
- Draft Prospect
- Posts: 248
- Joined: Sun Aug 15, 2010 9:18 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
That homer for Phelps his 7th of the year....one shy of the 8 he hit all of last year (a career high too). Late bloomer with the power.
-

TonyIBI - MLB Rookie
- Posts: 5047
- Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2008 11:03 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
TonyIPI wrote:That homer for Phelps his 7th of the year....one shy of the 8 he hit all of last year (a career high too). Late bloomer with the power.
Yeah Tony. As we talked about at ST, Phelps is so much more developed physically than when I saw him in college. I always thought he would hit well enough but the transformation from gap power to HR power is a little surprise to me. IMO his offense and defense put him ahead of Chisenhall when it comes to ML readiness and Kipnis is further behind. Both may still have greater upside but there is no denying Phelps additional power makes a difference.
- indianinkslinger
- Triple-A Stud
- Posts: 2493
- Joined: Fri Sep 19, 2008 12:11 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
Though Phelps success isnt much of a surprise, I think the fact that he is truthfully starting to level the playing field with Kipnis as to who will be our future 2 is surprising. Still early in the season, but with each game Phelps looks more and more likely to seize the opportunity as soon as he gets it. never thought I would say this, but Kipnis has his work cut out for him.
- criznit2009
- Double-A Hot Shot
- Posts: 1133
- Joined: Tue May 12, 2009 9:27 pm
- Location: Portland, OR
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
Hagadone called up
- Lloyd Christmas
- Draft Prospect
- Posts: 248
- Joined: Sun Aug 15, 2010 9:18 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
Lloyd Christmas wrote:Hagadone called up
I think Nick is ready for a greater challenge but we have seen many players altogether skip AAA and go onto the majors. I was hoping he would have gone north on highway, not south.
If there is a need here in the majors, I hope Nick gets called up. He is already burning one of his option years.
- MadThinker88
- Double-A Hot Shot
- Posts: 1678
- Joined: Wed Sep 17, 2008 10:48 am
- Location: Eau Claire, Wisconsin
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
A 7 inning complete game shutout for McAllister tonight to improve to 7-0, 2.42ERA
Went 7IP, 3H, 0R, 0B, 7K as the Clippers won 3-0.
Went 7IP, 3H, 0R, 0B, 7K as the Clippers won 3-0.
- dazindiansfanuk
- Double-A Hot Shot
- Posts: 1854
- Joined: Sat Sep 27, 2008 12:51 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
Question for Tony on McAllister; When you were posting the expanded box scores during spring training, I noticed that McAllister was shown with an average fastball of 93 and topping out at 95. I would have written it off as a crazy speed gun, but all the other velocities seemed dead on, AND McAllister had 9 ks and threw 7 shutout innings. Is he throwing a bit harder this year, or was that an exceptional performance? Thanks!!!
- stoike
- Draft Prospect
- Posts: 245
- Joined: Thu Oct 02, 2008 6:02 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
McAllister has been amazing this year, and yet more pitching depth for the Indians.
Heard the Indians are strongly considering Hagadone for bullpen in Cleveland sometime later in the year. Needs to show consistency, progress, and performance in Columbus and he could be ML option by All Star break if the need is that great.
Heard the Indians are strongly considering Hagadone for bullpen in Cleveland sometime later in the year. Needs to show consistency, progress, and performance in Columbus and he could be ML option by All Star break if the need is that great.
-

TonyIBI - MLB Rookie
- Posts: 5047
- Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2008 11:03 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
stoike wrote:Question for Tony on McAllister; When you were posting the expanded box scores during spring training, I noticed that McAllister was shown with an average fastball of 93 and topping out at 95. I would have written it off as a crazy speed gun, but all the other velocities seemed dead on, AND McAllister had 9 ks and threw 7 shutout innings. Is he throwing a bit harder this year, or was that an exceptional performance? Thanks!!!
Not throwing harder from what I know. One outing in spring he touched 94 MPH, but he mostly averaged 88-92 MPH and is still doing that.
-

TonyIBI - MLB Rookie
- Posts: 5047
- Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2008 11:03 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
TonyIPI wrote:stoike wrote:Question for Tony on McAllister; When you were posting the expanded box scores during spring training, I noticed that McAllister was shown with an average fastball of 93 and topping out at 95. I would have written it off as a crazy speed gun, but all the other velocities seemed dead on, AND McAllister had 9 ks and threw 7 shutout innings. Is he throwing a bit harder this year, or was that an exceptional performance? Thanks!!!
Not throwing harder from what I know. One outing in spring he touched 94 MPH, but he mostly averaged 88-92 MPH and is still doing that.
Thanks!
- stoike
- Draft Prospect
- Posts: 245
- Joined: Thu Oct 02, 2008 6:02 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
criznit2009 wrote:Though Phelps success isnt much of a surprise, I think the fact that he is truthfully starting to level the playing field with Kipnis as to who will be our future 2 is surprising. Still early in the season, but with each game Phelps looks more and more likely to seize the opportunity as soon as he gets it. never thought I would say this, but Kipnis has his work cut out for him.
I, much like you, just keep being pleasantly surprised by Cord Phelps. Through hard work, he has continued to develop his game in all phases, far beyond where I ever thought he could. But, baseball is a skills game more than any other, and he's successfully developed at a faster pace, and well beyond anyone's expectations.
I never thought I'd be saying this, but I believe he's moved ahead of Kipnis as our possible future 2nd baseman on the team. Which shocks me, personally. The added power this season, and versatility throughout the infield, again, surprising.
Didn't think he had the athleticism to play SS, but shows that he's passable even there...
Jerad Head is another that you just shake your head in disbelief.
One of the great things about this game is you have these stories that come along unexpectedly in player development.
- danh8
- Rookie Baller
- Posts: 296
- Joined: Wed May 05, 2010 12:49 am
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
TonyIPI wrote:McAllister has been amazing this year, and yet more pitching depth for the Indians.
Heard the Indians are strongly considering Hagadone for bullpen in Cleveland sometime later in the year. Needs to show consistency, progress, and performance in Columbus and he could be ML option by All Star break if the need is that great.
Both Hagadone and McCallister were breakout possibilities I had listed for this season. Hagadone simply for coming off his 1st year post surgery, and McCallister for having the patience needed to take a step back last year, and develop and alter a few pitches in order to make the next step to the majors.
Both seem to have made the jumps in performance I had hoped to see. Quite frankly, I think both are ready to show what they can do at the major league level... it won't be long.
I also anticipate us making some moves that take pitching depth within the organization to bring in some offensive weapons via trade at some point down the road.
- danh8
- Rookie Baller
- Posts: 296
- Joined: Wed May 05, 2010 12:49 am
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
TonyIPI wrote:stoike wrote:Question for Tony on McAllister; When you were posting the expanded box scores during spring training, I noticed that McAllister was shown with an average fastball of 93 and topping out at 95. I would have written it off as a crazy speed gun, but all the other velocities seemed dead on, AND McAllister had 9 ks and threw 7 shutout innings. Is he throwing a bit harder this year, or was that an exceptional performance? Thanks!!!
Not throwing harder from what I know. One outing in spring he touched 94 MPH, but he mostly averaged 88-92 MPH and is still doing that.
He's shown slightly more velocity, but where I've seen the greatest improvement is just the overall command of his secondary pitches, which have made his fastball all the more effective. He's had more success shwoing the fastball off the plate, and his out pitches have been predominantly his change/curve..
- danh8
- Rookie Baller
- Posts: 296
- Joined: Wed May 05, 2010 12:49 am
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
I'm really starting to like McAllister, thought he was a steal from the Yanks pitching at a high level until last yr's struggles pitching in AAA at age 22. McAllister has recovered well from the down season and is really showing he's almost ready.
I was just thinking about Nick Hagadone success this yr. Would the Tribe really put three lefty's in the pen together? Hagadone's potential as a shutdown arm though would be as good as adding a vet to the staff if he continues to pitch to his potential. I would guess it's highly likely w/o a lefty in the rotation it would provide a very interesting bullpen option ecspecially IF the the Tribe makes it into the offseason. The tribe would really be able to go righty lefty with the matchups.
I was just thinking about Nick Hagadone success this yr. Would the Tribe really put three lefty's in the pen together? Hagadone's potential as a shutdown arm though would be as good as adding a vet to the staff if he continues to pitch to his potential. I would guess it's highly likely w/o a lefty in the rotation it would provide a very interesting bullpen option ecspecially IF the the Tribe makes it into the offseason. The tribe would really be able to go righty lefty with the matchups.
- homerawayfromhome
- Double-A Hot Shot
- Posts: 1794
- Joined: Sun Aug 15, 2010 9:17 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
homerawayfromhome wrote:I was just thinking about Nick Hagadone success this yr. Would the Tribe really put three lefty's in the pen together? Hagadone's potential as a shutdown arm though would be as good as adding a vet to the staff if he continues to pitch to his potential.
I recall there being 3 lefties in the pen during 95 - Paul A/ Alan Embree/ Jim Poole.
Just noting that for people.
- MadThinker88
- Double-A Hot Shot
- Posts: 1678
- Joined: Wed Sep 17, 2008 10:48 am
- Location: Eau Claire, Wisconsin
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
MadThinker88 wrote:homerawayfromhome wrote:I was just thinking about Nick Hagadone success this yr. Would the Tribe really put three lefty's in the pen together? Hagadone's potential as a shutdown arm though would be as good as adding a vet to the staff if he continues to pitch to his potential.
I recall there being 3 lefties in the pen during 95 - Paul A/ Alan Embree/ Jim Poole.
Just noting that for people.
good catch
- jellis
- Triple-A Stud
- Posts: 3016
- Joined: Wed Sep 17, 2008 5:34 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
Jim Poole was a good pick up off the scrap heap. There's a lot of similarities between the 2 teams it seems.
- homerawayfromhome
- Double-A Hot Shot
- Posts: 1794
- Joined: Sun Aug 15, 2010 9:17 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
I know Jerad Head is primarly a OF but gets described as a jack of all trades a lot. Could he possibly play any 2nd or 3rd too if called up?
- criznit2009
- Double-A Hot Shot
- Posts: 1133
- Joined: Tue May 12, 2009 9:27 pm
- Location: Portland, OR
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
indianinkslinger wrote:TonyIPI wrote:That homer for Phelps his 7th of the year....one shy of the 8 he hit all of last year (a career high too). Late bloomer with the power.
Yeah Tony. As we talked about at ST, Phelps is so much more developed physically than when I saw him in college. I always thought he would hit well enough but the transformation from gap power to HR power is a little surprise to me. IMO his offense and defense put him ahead of Chisenhall when it comes to ML readiness and Kipnis is further behind. Both may still have greater upside but there is no denying Phelps additional power makes a difference.
Strength is always the last to develop. Look at power lifting competitions, most in the winners circle are mid to upper 30's and some in their 40's. This is what makes me a little more patient with prospects, most don't develop until late 20's while some will develop a little earlier. Hell a lot of players don't stop growing until their late 20's. To me a guy in his mid 20's is just starting to realize his potential physically and mature mentally and this seems to be where a lot of people want to cast them aside.
- Chip Davis
- Draft Prospect
- Posts: 152
- Joined: Tue Mar 29, 2011 9:44 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
Chip Davis wrote:indianinkslinger wrote:TonyIPI wrote:That homer for Phelps his 7th of the year....one shy of the 8 he hit all of last year (a career high too). Late bloomer with the power.
Yeah Tony. As we talked about at ST, Phelps is so much more developed physically than when I saw him in college. I always thought he would hit well enough but the transformation from gap power to HR power is a little surprise to me. IMO his offense and defense put him ahead of Chisenhall when it comes to ML readiness and Kipnis is further behind. Both may still have greater upside but there is no denying Phelps additional power makes a difference.
Strength is always the last to develop. Look at power lifting competitions, most in the winners circle are mid to upper 30's and some in their 40's. This is what makes me a little more patient with prospects, most don't develop until late 20's while some will develop a little earlier. Hell a lot of players don't stop growing until their late 20's. To me a guy in his mid 20's is just starting to realize his potential physically and mature mentally and this seems to be where a lot of people want to cast them aside.
Absolutely agree Chip. You weren't around for the great debates I had about Phelps with Voldemort. Phelps had decent bat speed in College but strictly "aluminum" power, mostly because he hit line drives with little loft and backspin. Without looking at my old notes, i seem to recall he projected more power from the right side. Late last year i noticed some subtle changes is his stroke, especially from the left side. Checked it out thoroughly in ST and he now gets a better turn with increased loft and bat speed to go along with the improved strength.
He is not my only organizational miss in that regard. I am constantly reminded of a conversation Art Gold and I had at ST when we saw Michael Brantley for the first time after the trade. Both of us felt that the Indians would be fortunate indeed if Brantley had 10 HR power in the majors and 15 was his absolute max. And we both felt he would be as big as he is. I did not see his growth to include the ability to loft be ball against RHP which he has developed. Both Art and i knew he had great bat speed. If Brantley learns to do the same to LHP, then i would say that both Art and I underestimated him. Time will tell for both.

- indianinkslinger
- Triple-A Stud
- Posts: 2493
- Joined: Fri Sep 19, 2008 12:11 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
You have to figure that Goedert, McBride or Weglarz have to be on their way up to AAA at this point, with all the recent promotion. Only problem being that none of them play CF.
-

Edible14 - Single-A Phenom
- Posts: 903
- Joined: Sun Apr 04, 2010 11:49 am
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
So who's on the welcoming committee to greet Nick Hagacone to the Clippers?
- GeronimoSon
- Triple-A Stud
- Posts: 3264
- Joined: Sat Oct 30, 2010 6:17 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
criznit2009 wrote:I know Jerad Head is primarly a OF but gets described as a jack of all trades a lot. Could he possibly play any 2nd or 3rd too if called up?
Head is not a very good defender, but is passable at the corners in the OF and INF. He can also be used in a pinch at SS, 2B, CF and even C. He can play every position, and for one game be fine. Not everyday though.
-

TonyIBI - MLB Rookie
- Posts: 5047
- Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2008 11:03 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
Edible14 wrote:You have to figure that Goedert, McBride or Weglarz have to be on their way up to AAA at this point, with all the recent promotion. Only problem being that none of them play CF.
Goedert and Weglarz will certainly be up in COlumbus very soon. Also don't forget about Nick Johnson.
McBride is staying in Akron. Low priority guy and too many other guys above him.
-

TonyIBI - MLB Rookie
- Posts: 5047
- Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2008 11:03 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
I'll go out on a limb and say McBride won't stay in Akron for long. It's hard for me to comprehend how such a good defensive catcher at one point can't play the field, sorry, I'm not buying it. The kid absolutely destroys mistakes over the plate, probably better than anyone in the organization except for maybe Weglarz. A little more patience or a little better strike zone judgement sends this kid into orbit, offensively speaking. He could be the right handed power bat the team needs if that OBP goes up a tic or two. Then again he could peeter out, but I'm going with the 1st scenario. I picked him for my breakout candidate and I'm sticking with him.
- Chip Davis
- Draft Prospect
- Posts: 152
- Joined: Tue Mar 29, 2011 9:44 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
Chip ... just remember that a mistake hitter does well in the minors but turns out to be a Marte in the majors because there are fewer mistakes and they find your holes and keep pounding you. I was on the McBride bandwagon but not so much anymore. In his third year of AA, he should be a .280 to .300 hitter and he is sitting at .250. And, I saw him at one game at 1B and wasn't to impressed for being a good defensive catcher ... I scratched my head as well as he couldn't smoother a ball to him which I would have expected out of a catcher and his training.
- petes999
- Single-A Phenom
- Posts: 559
- Joined: Sun Sep 28, 2008 6:02 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
I'm about as big of a fan as McBride as you will find. But, that having been said, he's no longer much of a prospect. If he had any ML value at all to the Indians they wouldn't have buried him at Akron and he would be in Columbus. THe guys who have value are pushed upward or get lots of chances. Actions speak louder than words.
-

TonyIBI - MLB Rookie
- Posts: 5047
- Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2008 11:03 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
Steven Wright called up to Columbus.... not sure if it's just an emergency situation.
Has come on in relief in the 6th inning.
Has come on in relief in the 6th inning.
- dazindiansfanuk
- Double-A Hot Shot
- Posts: 1854
- Joined: Sat Sep 27, 2008 12:51 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
dazindiansfanuk wrote:Steven Wright called up to Columbus.... not sure if it's just an emergency situation.
Has come on in relief in the 6th inning.
With all the various call-ups to Cleveland, injuries and other things, keep things straight in Cbus has likely been a challenge.
- MadThinker88
- Double-A Hot Shot
- Posts: 1678
- Joined: Wed Sep 17, 2008 10:48 am
- Location: Eau Claire, Wisconsin
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
petes999 wrote:Chip ... just remember that a mistake hitter does well in the minors but turns out to be a Marte in the majors because there are fewer mistakes and they find your holes and keep pounding you.
That was pretty much the thought on Goedert last year IIRC. Similar reasoning has tried to explain why guys like LaPorta and Duncan don't translate to the show as well.
As for Wright, not surprising to see him up given his age. I was wondering if they would move him back to the bullpen, or if being a knuckleballer now would mean that he could be a starting option.
-

Edible14 - Single-A Phenom
- Posts: 903
- Joined: Sun Apr 04, 2010 11:49 am
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
I believe the Wright call to Columbus is short term. Not a 100% on that, but I think he is heading back to KIN/LC to work in the rotation here very soon.
-

TonyIBI - MLB Rookie
- Posts: 5047
- Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2008 11:03 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
Langwell and Popham promoted to Columbus. Popham is obviously a short term option there, but Langwell may stick. Good for him.
Looks like a big day of movement in the system with pitchers is coming.
Looks like a big day of movement in the system with pitchers is coming.
-

TonyIBI - MLB Rookie
- Posts: 5047
- Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2008 11:03 pm
Re: 2011 Columbus Clippers Thread
TonyIPI wrote:Langwell and Popham promoted to Columbus. Popham is obviously a short term option there, but Langwell may stick. Good for him.
Looks like a big day of movement in the system with pitchers is coming.
Surprised it's Langwell instead of CC Lee, Berger or Espino. Actually, I've been wondering why Espino doesn't take the long relief/spot starter role in AAA that Martinez has. Is he getting more appearances in Akron this way?
-

Edible14 - Single-A Phenom
- Posts: 903
- Joined: Sun Apr 04, 2010 11:49 am
Return to Indians Prospect Talk
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest




